Did I Make the Right Decision?

Willow Creek | April 24, 2026


How to Find Peace After You Choose

Making a decision isn’t always the hardest part—it might be everything that comes after.

You choose the school. Take the job. End the relationship. Start over. Say yes. Say no. And then, days later, the second-guessing begins.

Did I make the right decision?

If you have asked that question, you are in good company. Most meaningful decisions come with some level of doubt, simply because they matter.

Here are a few things to remember when you can’t stop replaying the choice you made.

1. Second-guessing does not automatically mean you chose wrong.
It usually means the decision was costly, significant, or emotional. Your mind is trying to protect you from pain. That does not make it a trustworthy guide.

2. Peace is not the same as certainty.
Many people assume that if they made the right choice, they would instantly feel calm. But sometimes peace grows over time, not all at once in the moment of choosing.

3. Regret is a terrible GPS.
Regret loves imaginary versions of life that do not exist. It compares your real life to fantasy outcomes you cannot verify. That is why “what if” thinking can keep you stuck for a long time.

4. God is bigger than your imperfect choices.
This is where real hope begins. Your future is not hanging by a thread because of one imperfect decision. God is faithful, present, and able to work even in situations that feel messy or uncertain.

5. Focus on today’s obedience.
You may not be able to answer every question about the future, but you can ask a better question today: What does faithfulness look like right now? Use that as a guide.

If you are carrying the weight of a past decision, you need room to breathe, trust, and move forward again. That is one of the reasons we are doing God, Is That You? Because following God is not about never making mistakes. It is about learning to trust the One who leads us.